How about a time machine pick....Clyde 'Cannonball' Crabtree, halfback on our 1928 team and our first All American.
Actually my earliest memories of Gator football was of Otis Boggs sending that terrific duo of Rick Casares and J. Papa Hall into our living room with my Dad and Grandad huddled around the old Emerson. Sweet memories.
Addazio certainly isn’t lovable but doesn’t come close to touching the slime of 3/4 of those (plus whatever you think of durkin)
I would go Neal, between the 2. The best comparison I can come up with in the current years is …Neal more Scarlett, John L more Perine. Both brought an edge in their own way.