Not sure what you're looking at, but according to Yahoo Sports, we have plenty of room to improve: "Florida football brought in one of the best recruiting classes in recent memory this week when the early signing period opened on Wednesday. Of the 20 members of the 2023 cycle who signed on with the Gators, 16 were four-star-rated prospects — which are included with five-star prospects in the blue-chip designation used in recruiting circles. That 80% clue-chip ratio is the best that the program has achieved dating back to Urban Meyer’s final season in Gainesville, which resulted in an 85% blue-chip mark. In between these two points, the Orange and Blue saw some very lean years including a paltry 35% ratio in 2022."
That would be consensus four stars. The others were all four stars on at least one of the major agencies
Because on person used consensus four stars and the other use four star in at least one ranking service as stated in paragraphs 2 and 3.