It seems they both won for their specific sports: Jasmine Moore and Trinity Thomas Receive 2023 Honda Awards - Florida Gators
They were both tops in their sports. They both received the Honda Award for their sport. All there are Honda Award winners. EDIT: Caitlin Clark wins Collegiate Women's Athlete of the Year | AP News The overall Honda Award winner was Caitlin Clark of Iowa's women's basketball. How could the decision be otherwise with the national stage she was given in the NCAA Final Four? She practically single-handedly beat defending champion South Carolina before Iowa bowed out in the final against LSU.