i felt this way too (and I mistakenly put this post into this thread and not the 2024 recruiting thread lol)
It wasn't what his stats were it was the fact he is a once in a generation physical specimen that got him a top 10 grade. Dude has the body of Adonis and a nuclear weapon as a arm...but field performance and that 53.8% completion rate stink up the joint.
Two kinds of salt cats over here on the easy coast. Sail cats are good eating and can be a fun fight. The other.. trash bait stealers